As a former Pentecostal evangelist; when I left the church
one of the first things I had to try to explain was how I was able to do the
things I did during a typical service, let me explain. When I would preach people
claimed later to have been healed, set free from demonic possession or
oppression, received gifts of the Spirit they previously did not have such as
speaking in tongues (glossolalia), or being baptized in the Holy Spirit.
When I prayed for people they typically fell over without me
even touching them, what was more amazing which at times even shocked me; was
that I was able to do this with the same effects from clear across the room by
simply pointing at someone! Sometimes I would stare at someone and they would
pass out and later testify that they were overcome by the presence of the Holy
Spirit! At the time I truly believed that I was a man who was filled with the
Spirit and had what the Pentecostals like to call the anointing.
In the Old Testament when one was chosen King he was
anointed by the priests in a ceremony which typically meant that he was chosen
by God as the people’s ruler. Pentecostals on the other hand believed in a
spiritual anointing that only came upon a chosen few in which God himself would
pour out his Spirit upon them and grant them amazing powers for use in the
ministry. These gifts are listed in the book of 1 Corinthians 12:8-10 in all the
number of the gifts of the Spirit are nine. During my ministry I can honestly
say that at one time or another I have utilized each and every one of these
gifts.
The first time that I began to doubt the origin of the “powers”
was when I was watching a television documentary about an Indian ceremony that
had to do with the dance of the serpent. Basically, there were some girls all
dressed in white dresses and they were dancing around a ritualistic circle
meant to conjure the spirit of some serpent deity. As the ritual wore on the
girls began to mimic the movements of a snake as they supposedly succumbed to
the possession of the spirit deity. They began to writhe sensually on the
ground etc. I remember the first thought that crossed my mind upon seeing that
ritual was “that’s not that different from what happens in my church!”
In a typical Pentecostal service it is not uncommon to see
men and women alike passing out suddenly, or begin to “speak in tongues”
loudly,crying, or to get caught in ecstasy as they raise their arms in the air and
shout hallelujah, or even begin jumping up and down uncontrollably. All of
these are interpreted as the working of the Spirit in them. But is it really?
It is also important to note that a lot of these manifestations are all psycho-emotional but that is something we could talk about in another post.One of the first places I began to look for answers was in the field of
hypnosis. I had seen many stage hypnotists on television specials make people
do incredible things through the power of suggestion.
In hypnosis as in religion, the first thing you must do is
surrender and trust the person you are surrendering to. Pentecostalism hammers
into your psyche to let go and let God’s Spirit have his way with you. A minister may place his hands on your head or
shoulders and shout in your ear “let go stop resisting the Spirit of the Lord
is doing a work in you.” Meanwhile while all of this is going on you have the
rest of the congregation yelling “touch him/her Lord let them feel your power
baptize them with your Holy Spirit!”
There is loud music meant to help you let go of your
inhibitions and relax to put you in the right state of mind. Before you know it
you either pass out or start speaking in tongues which contrary to what many
believe who have not had this experience you are actually very conscious and
aware of your surroundings when this happens.
Basically, you are in a hypnotic trance induced by the combination of
previous indoctrination to your churches beliefs, the loud music, the prayers
of a “holy man,” and the egging on of the rest of the congregation with
supporting shouts and prayers. But this could also happen just by hearing the
minister’s voice as he preaches and shouts his message of salvation at the top
of his lungs.
Think of the minister as the hypnotist, his touch or stare,
the yelling, the music, the egging on of your fellow believers, and you have
the perfect formula for a hypnotic induction. As stated before the
auto-suggestion is already taken care of with the daily indoctrinations you
receive while you remain a member of that church and fraternize with the elders
of the congregation. All of these things serve as tools to the
hypnotist/evangelist.
I can attest that when I was an evangelist I was unaware of
these techniques and utilized them unknowingly. I was basically following the
standard rituals as taught to me by the church and as I participated in and
observed several times a week. Not all ministers in these churches use these
techniques to deceive, although there might be a few who know exactly what they
are doing.
In closing, all of these phenomena are nothing more than
events created in the mind. They are altered mental states that seemingly
produce physical results such as faith healing or deliverance from demonic oppression
or possession. A lot of the so called healings you hear about in these
congregations are actually nothing more than the placebo effect in action.
These so called maladies are nothing more than psycho-somatic disorders and the
rituals of the church serve as the cure (placebo) of an imaginary problem.
My husband was the recipient of 'healing hands' from his sister when she visited us and even though he was not aware at the time of her prayers being directed to his lower back he had a temporary reprieve from his pain. I can understand the placebo effect when you want relief from a mallady but it's nothing short of amazing when you get relief after someone just brushes their hand across your back at a time when you're not expecting it. He is not a believer and was not surprised when the pain came back after two days but the short-lived episode was an eye opener for him. I can't explain it and there certainly was no circus atmosphere involved. For me, faith healing is right up there with extraordinary claims requiring extraordinary evidence...to have any merit amputees would have to regrow limbs and and paralyzed people would have to be able to move again.
ReplyDeleteFacinating to hear first hand account from one who has been there and done that.
ReplyDeleteI wonder to what degree the hypnotic effect is dependent on, or enhanced by, lower intelligence of the congregant, along with their necessary religious preparation. My educated guess is that the least intelligent would be most susseptible to the suggestions of the minister.
It's not really about intelligence in my opinion because as you know there are bonafide scientists that are actually Christians. In fact, there are many intelligent people that are even fundamentalists as well. I think it's about the degree of indoctrination that they have received. There is also the theory that intelligent people tend to compartmentalize their rational mind from their faith beliefs.
ReplyDeleteWhat I am trying to say Hump is that once you are indoctrinated you tend to separate your rational mind from your faith. I did exactly that and it wasn't till I began to actually question my faith that I began to activate my rational mind and apply it to the scriptures and what I believed at the time. It wasn't an easy escape for me as I have made clear before. In the end breaking free from radical beliefs is rather difficult and usually something or some event has to trigger your desire to do so.
ReplyDeleteChat...
ReplyDeletefully understand compartmentalization. and yes, some sicentisists are beievers. But here's the thing, if 93% of the National academy of science are non-believers (97% of the Royal Academy in the UK), that leaves 7% believers.
Of those 7%, how many would we find flopping on the floor, talking in tonngues, and otherwise participating in charasmatic hysteria? I'm going to proffer none.
Could that be that the greatest scentific minds are the greatest scientific minds because they were [coincidently] not raised among extreme religiosity? That some significant proportion are Jews and other non-xtian religionists? Or is it because they rejected such extremist religiosity because of their intellectual advantage?
I don't know the answer, perhaps a mix of the three is likely. Just thinking out loud.
PS: It also begs the question as to why the greatest scientific minds in the world reject religion in such a large proportion if intellect where not a major cause for non-belief?
ReplyDeleteHump, as far as the propensity of non-belief of the intellectual goes I wholeheartedly agree with you. The numbers don't lie on that issue. On the other hand I believe that your upbringing and the degree of your indoctrination has a lot to do with how far you take those beliefs. Not to mention how hard you are willing to fight to defend those beliefs.
ReplyDeleteI do think that you might have a point regarding the charismatics such as the Pentecostals and their propensities to believe in the supernatural. I guess I took personal offense because I don't consider myself to be less intelligent than the next guy, and although I did not go to college ( I choose military service)I fell victim to the insanity of Pentecostalism.
But I attribute my personal experience to my Hispanic culture. Hispanics in my view tend to be very superstitious and religious the same goes for the Afro-American community. Once I was able to break away from the fears that came with my cultural superstitions regarding God I was able to free my mind indefinitely from all forms of superstition.
I fully agree upbringing/early indoctrination plays an enormous part. It could well be that a person with a high IQ raised in a fundamentalist household is actually stunted or at least dissuaded from persuing a career in science and questioning since reason is the enemy of faith. Religion seems to waste perfectly good minds; and less intelligent people tend to gravitate toward religious belief... not exclusively less intelligent, just predominantly.
ReplyDeleteAnd I did not mean to imply that on an individual basis all relgionists are less intelligent than atheists. That would be nuts. The 30+ studies from the 30's through the 80's which I mentioned in my first boook, and which are available through a google search, show stong correlation between degree of religiosity and a lower level of intelligence. But that's an aggregate result. Individually there must be tens of thousands of religionists smarter than me .. and certainly millions who spell better :)
The fact that people are using religion to fill their own interests, ecstasy or money or power or fame, doesn't mean that someone has to say No to God his Creator. All these movements are not biblical either. If we read the Bible seriously and not superficially we will by surprise find that Paul already Condemned this attitutde to Corinthian Church, and that the tongues of Pentecost were real tongues..and not mystical as many say. Today i never found any Church where someone is speaking my mother Language that is the ancient Greek. So i believe this manifestation of the Holy Spirit is useless today, with all the translators and books we have. My friend, if i can call you like this (by permission), if people doesnt understand the Bible and make so many errors, doesn't mean we have to forget the Love of Jesus on the Cross for everyone of us. Jesus still loves you and me, and Waits you to serve Him with your new state of Truth. Greeting from Milano (Italy) (i passed through same experiences, but thanks God i found the real peace in Jesus Himself and not superstitions) God bless everybody
ReplyDeleteThe fact that people are using religion to fill their own interests, ecstasy or money or power or fame, doesn't mean that someone has to say No to God his Creator. All these movements are not biblical either. If we read the Bible seriously and not superficially we will by surprise find that Paul already Condemned this attitutde to Corinthian Church, and that the tongues of Pentecost were real tongues..and not mystical as many say. Today i never found any Church where someone is speaking my mother Language that is the ancient Greek. So i believe this manifestation of the Holy Spirit is useless today, with all the translators and books we have. My friend, if i can call you like this (by permission), if people doesnt understand the Bible and make so many errors, doesn't mean we have to forget the Love of Jesus on the Cross for everyone of us. Jesus still loves you and me, and Waits you to serve Him with your new state of Truth. Greeting from Milano (Italy) (i passed through so called churches with the same experiences, but thanks God i found the real peace in Jesus Himself and not superstitions) God bless everybody
ReplyDeleteAs a kid I grew up in a charismatic AG Church. Its nice to read like minded people who experienced these things too. For me, though, it was scary. I never got hypnotized, though, I felt like I came very close as I was leaving childhood going into my teenage years. I thought because I rejected the hypnosis I was fighting the "Spirit." For a few years I lived in extreme fear and anxiety of Hell because of this. This is why religion is very, very bad. If anyone ever tried to put the "fear of God" in to my daughter, knowing what I went though, I would be very, very angry!
ReplyDeleteThanks for commenting. I find as an atheist who has been through it that this is one of the missing components in those atheists that have never had these types of exepriences with religious beliefs. They don't fully comprehend the profundity of the influence of charismatic beliefs. Once it has you its influence goes deep and it's very difficult to break free from.
Delete